Crumbl Cookies’ Impact: Why Kalani Sitake Chose to Stay at BYU Over Penn State

In a dramatic turn of events during the coaching search for Penn State’s football program, Kalani Sitake, head coach of BYU, appeared poised to take the reins at the university. However, significant support from influential figures at BYU, particularly Jason McGowan, CEO of Crumbl Cookies, altered the course of this narrative.

This article explores the complex circumstances that led to Sitake’s decision to remain at his alma mater, emphasizing the vital role of dedicated supporters and substantial financial backing.

The unexpected intervention

As speculation mounted about Sitake being the leading candidate for the Penn State position, the Cougars faced a precarious situation. With ambitions of reaching the College Football Playoff, retaining Sitake became critical.

McGowan, recognizing the urgency, took it upon himself to rally the BYU community. His approach was both unconventional and heartfelt, urging fans to express their appreciation for Sitake through a social media campaign he termed a love bomb. This initiative aimed to highlight the admiration and respect the community held for their coach.

A sweet strategy

Offering enticing rewards, including tickets to the Big 12 championship game, McGowan’s call to action resonated deeply with fans. The response was overwhelming, as messages of support flooded social media, creating a wave of goodwill that Sitake could not overlook.

During the announcement of his contract extension, Sitake was visibly moved, sharing, “It was an incredible feeling of appreciation from everyone. How could I possibly walk away from that?”

Financial backing reinforces loyalty

While emotional support significantly influenced Sitake’s decision, the financial commitment from BYU was equally compelling. Reports indicated that the university was prepared to dedicate a substantial portion of its NIL budget to the football program, with estimates suggesting up to $10 million allocated for Sitake’s future.

This financial assurance enabled Sitake to focus not only on his own compensation but also on ensuring that his coaching staff and players received the necessary support. “It’s not solely about my salary; it’s about taking care of the entire team,” he emphasized, a perspective that resonated with the administration’s goal to cultivate a winning culture.

The aftermath of Penn State’s pursuit

Following Sitake’s decision to stay at BYU, the Nittany Lions found themselves at a crossroads. With several top candidates, including Sitake, off the board, the search for a new head coach became increasingly difficult. The pressure mounted on Penn State’s athletic director, Pat Kraft, to identify a viable candidate amid a shrinking pool.

During this challenging period, interim coach Terry Smith emerged as a potential candidate for the permanent head coaching position. Smith’s connection to the program and the support he received from players provided a foundation for consideration, although concerns remained about his ability to lead the team to future success.

New chapter for BYU

This article explores the complex circumstances that led to Sitake’s decision to remain at his alma mater, emphasizing the vital role of dedicated supporters and substantial financial backing.0

This article explores the complex circumstances that led to Sitake’s decision to remain at his alma mater, emphasizing the vital role of dedicated supporters and substantial financial backing.1