Table of Contents
Proceedings in the Manitoba legislature took a surprising turn when a sound resembling a baby’s cry echoed through the chamber. This incident occurred during a heated debate concerning a proposed bill that would allow judges to intervene if the government invokes the notwithstanding clause.
The noise, made by opposition member Jeff Wharton, sparked a series of reactions that underscored the ongoing tensions between the political parties.
Context of the debate
During the session, Premier Wab Kinew was addressing the assembly when Wharton interrupted with the infantile sound.
Kinew, representing the New Democratic Party (NDP), expressed his discontent, arguing that such mockery undermined serious issues tied to Canadian history, particularly the voting rights of First Nations individuals. He pointed out that many of his constituents, including his own father, faced significant obstacles to voting, an ongoing issue that remains pertinent.
Reactions and accusations
Wharton defended his actions, stating that the “waah waah” sound was a response to Kinew’s remarks regarding the perceived entitlement of the Progressive Conservatives compared to the hard work of the NDP. He emphasized that his comment targeted the perceived arrogance of the ruling party, not a personal insult to Kinew or his family’s history.
“The premier was painting a false narrative about how hard my colleagues are working for Manitobans,” Wharton said.
In contrast, Kinew and his allies quickly labeled Wharton’s remarks as disrespectful. David Pankratz, the NDP’s deputy house leader, described it as “childish mockery”, particularly considering the context of their discussion, which involved the historical disenfranchisement of Indigenous communities.
Escalating tensions in the chamber
This incident is part of a larger pattern in a tumultuous legislative session characterized by frequent interruptions and heated exchanges. Speaker Tom Lindsey has issued multiple warnings to both sides to uphold decorum. Previous disputes included Kinew labeling former premier Heather Stefanson a “degenerate”, while Tory Wayne Ewasko remarked that Kinew would be remembered as the only premier charged with domestic violence, referencing Kinew’s past legal issues that were ultimately resolved.
Calls for improved conduct
Following recent outbursts, Lindsey emphasized the necessity for a more respectful atmosphere within the legislature. He expressed disappointment regarding the behaviors displayed by both parties, stating, “The actions displayed today do not represent the values of the people of Manitoba.” As the session approaches its conclusion, the NDP is advocating for a bill that would allow detaining individuals under the influence of drugs for up to 72 hours. This proposal has faced opposition from the Tories, who have suggested amendments.
The ongoing disputes within the legislature highlight a significant political divide in Manitoba, as both parties grapple with their priorities and strategies. With the session nearing its end, the repercussions of this incident may continue to affect public perception and future legislative interactions.
