Table of Contents
The San Francisco Unified School District (SFUSD) has decided to pause its proposed “Grading for Equity” strategy following a wave of criticism from community members, educators, and politicians. This decision reflects the growing concerns about educational standards and the implications of such grading practices on student achievement.
Understanding the proposed grading system
The “Grading for Equity” initiative aimed to shift the focus of student assessments by allowing multiple retakes of final exams while disregarding homework, attendance, and punctuality in determining final grades. Under this system, a student could potentially receive an A for scoring 80% on an exam, while a score as low as 21% could still result in a passing grade of D.
This radical approach was intended to create a more inclusive environment, but it raised significant eyebrows among educators and parents alike.
Community response and political backlash
Community leaders, including San Francisco Mayor Daniel Lurie, voiced strong opposition to the proposed grading changes.
Lurie emphasized that the educational system should prepare students for success, arguing that the proposed grading system would not achieve that goal. His sentiments were echoed by various politicians, including U.S. Representatives Kevin Kiley and Ro Khanna, who criticized the initiative as a misguided attempt to address educational disparities.
Kiley sarcastically referred to the proposal as a “brilliant solution” for failing schools, while Khanna highlighted the importance of hard work and excellence in education.
The future of grading practices in SFUSD
In light of the backlash, Superintendent Maria Su announced that no changes would be implemented at this time.
She acknowledged the concerns raised by the community and stated that the district remains committed to high standards for all students. The SFUSD aims to prioritize learning and mastery, ensuring that any future changes to grading practices genuinely benefit students.
As discussions continue, it is clear that the conversation around educational equity and grading standards will remain a hot topic in San Francisco and beyond.
