Table of Contents
The evolution of horror films on digital platforms
The realm of horror films has experienced notable changes, particularly with the rise of platforms like YouTube. Chris Stuckmann, a former film critic who transitioned to directing, has made his debut with the chilling film Shelby Oaks.
This movie intricately weaves themes of disappearance and supernatural horror, while drawing inspiration from the familiar landscape of online culture.
A captivating narrative unfolds
At the core of the narrative is the mysterious case of Riley Brennan, played by Sarah Durn, who vanishes alongside her friends during a ghost-hunting adventure.
The story is set in the fictional town of Shelby Oaks, where Riley and her companions, known as the Paranormal Paranoids, explore eerie locations, ultimately facing an ominous fate. The film begins with a mockumentary style, transitioning seamlessly into a more traditional horror format, showcasing Stuckmann’s unique background in online media.
The journey of a filmmaker
Filmmaker Stuckmann’s path to directing illustrates a story of dedication and resilience. He crafted multiple spec scripts and sought opportunities at various film festivals to pitch his ideas. “I didn’t want to rely on just one script,” he stated, underscoring the importance of networking.
His persistence bore fruit when he met producer Aaron Koontz at Fantastic Fest in 2019. This encounter marked the beginning of the development of Shelby Oaks.
Stuckmann selected Darke County, Ohio, as the film’s setting, portraying a fictional representation that captures the essence of rural horror.
The name resonated with him, inspiring the creation of a mini cinematic universe that he aims to expand in future projects. This intentional world-building is crucial for immersing audiences in the film’s chilling atmosphere.
Blending modern media with horror
The film distinguishes itself through its innovative storytelling techniques. Director Chris Stuckmann draws inspiration from reaction videos, which are popular on platforms such as YouTube. He posits that viewers find enjoyment in witnessing genuine emotional responses, a concept highlighted in a poignant scene where Mia, Riley’s sister, watches a chilling videotape. This moment acts as a bridge, connecting the audience’s feelings to the unfolding narrative and underscoring the film’s integration of diverse media.
Originally envisioned as a mockumentary, the film evolved into a more complex narrative. Stuckmann noted that traditional mockumentaries often acknowledge their fictional status, allowing for a playful tone. He took advantage of this by blending scripted scares with unexpected found footage, resulting in a distinctive cinematic experience.
Exploring the unsettling conclusion
The climax of Shelby Oaks highlights director Stuckmann’s dedication to creating a memorable emotional experience. He asserts that effective horror films often forgo comforting endings. The film’s resolution reflects the trauma and scars that linger from past experiences, likening them to a crack in a window that, if neglected, can lead to chaos.
As Mia embarks on her quest to find her sister, the narrative darkens, introducing themes of loss and the burden of unresolved trauma. The chilling discovery of a cassette tape marked Shelby Oaks pushes the storyline into deeper territory, prompting her to explore the sinister history of the abandoned prison connected to Riley’s disappearance. This journey is filled with disturbing revelations that intensify the suspense.
Critiques and reflections on the genre
Despite its ambition, the film has received mixed reviews. Some critics argue that Stuckmann’s film relies heavily on established horror tropes, lacking the innovative flair that distinguishes successful entries in the genre. Others, however, appreciate the film’s nod to past influences, recognizing its nostalgic homage to horror conventions.
Ultimately, Shelby Oaks represents a generational shift in horror filmmaking, underscoring the impact of digital media on storytelling. As filmmakers like Stuckmann emerge from the YouTube landscape, they offer fresh perspectives that reflect contemporary viewing habits. The film’s exploration of loss, fear, and the unknown resonates with today’s audience, effectively situating it within the evolving horror genre.
Shelby Oaks serves as a compelling exploration of fear and the search for truth, while also paying homage to the roots of horror storytelling. Its unique blend of media and emotional depth makes it a noteworthy addition to the genre.



