The Department of Justice has officially surrendered its attempt to interfere in the outcome of Alaska’s recent U.S. Senate race. On Thursday, federal attorneys filed documents with the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, asking that the civil lawsuit they initiated last month be declared moot. The original suit sought to prevent state officials from certifying the election results unless it could be proven that incumbent Republican Senator Dan S. Sullivan had emerged victorious.
This development follows the confirmation that Democratic challenger Mary Peltola won the contest outright this week. Her victory meant that the specific legal remedy requested by the administration (separating and investigating ballots cast for a similarly named independent candidate, Dan J. Sullivan) was no longer applicable. The government acknowledged that there was now no mechanism to determine if voters had been confused by the presence of two candidates sharing the same surname.
Legal Basis for Withdrawal
In their filing, Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward stated that the United States brought the lawsuit to ensure Alaska fulfilled its obligation to protect election integrity. However, he conceded that the department “reluctantly acknowledges” that the means to vindicate any alleged injury have disappeared. The core argument of the administration had been that the inclusion of Dan J. Sullivan on the ballot alongside the incumbent was a deliberate stunt designed to defraud voters.
Despite the withdrawal, the DOJ maintained that the lower court’s initial dismissal of the case should still be overturned. They argued that the district court erred in refusing to allow an investigation into voter confusion. Nevertheless, with Peltola securing more than 50% of the vote, the practical impact of the separate Sullivan candidate was nullified. The winner did not need to rely on ranked-choice tabulation, as her first-place votes constituted a majority on their own.
Background of the Controversy
The controversy intensified in October when President Donald Trump publicly insisted that he was responsible for initiating the legal action. During a campaign blitz, he told reporters, “I’m the one that said do it,” claiming that the dual-Sullivan scenario would inevitably confuse the electorate. He further accused Peltola’s campaign of recruiting the independent candidate to siphon votes away from the senator, labeling the situation as “voter fraud at the highest level.”
These allegations were fueled by reports suggesting coordination between Peltola’s team and Dan J. Sullivan. While Peltola denied any wrongdoing, the accusations led to calls for her prosecution and removal from the ballot. Prior to these events, the Alaska supreme court had ruled in June that Dan J. Sullivan was eligible to remain on the ballot, a decision that stood despite subsequent federal challenges.
A federal judge in Alaska rejected the administration’s plea to segregate ballots on November 1, characterizing the lawsuit as meritless. This ruling was supported by voting trends which indicated that Alaskans were not significantly confused by the name similarity. Even before the final count, Peltola’s lead exceeded the total votes received by Dan J. Sullivan, making it mathematically impossible for the look-alike candidate to have altered the outcome.
Broader Context of Federal Intervention
Alaska was not the only location where the Trump administration attempted to intervene in state-run elections. In California, the Justice Department demanded that officials set aside approximately 20,000 ballots allegedly sent to noncitizens. State officials countered that the list provided was outdated and included legitimate voters. The Supreme Court ultimately rejected those efforts just a day before the election, leading the DOJ to dismiss that separate lawsuit later that week.
The resolution of the Alaska case highlights the limits of federal authority over state election processes. Although investigations into the recruitment of Dan J. Sullivan continue, including a criminal inquiry announced by U.S. Attorney Michael Heyman, they do not pose a legal obstacle to the certification of Peltola’s victory. If confirmed, Peltola will become the first Indigenous Alaskan elected to the U.S. Senate, joining a chamber where the balance of power hinges on such contested races.



